Is this the cure for your Harry Potter hangover?


unnamed
Image from Amazon

About the Book

  • Author: Shaun Hume
  • Genres: Fantasy
  • Released on: 31st October, 2012

I received a copy of this book from the author in exchange for an honest review.


Goodreads Synopsis

Ewan Pendle was weird. Really weird. At least, that’s what everyone told him. Then again, being able to see monsters that no one else could wasn’t exactly normal …

Thinking he has been moved off to live with his eleventh foster family, Ewan is instead told he is a Lenitnes, one of an ancient race of peoples who can alone see the real ‘Creatures’ which inhabit the earth. He is taken in by Enola, the mysterious sword carrying Grand Master of Firedrake Lyceum, a labyrinth of halls and rooms in the middle of London where other children, just like Ewan, go to learn the ways of the Creatures.


My Thoughts

This book has been compared to and has even been described by some readers as the cure for the HP hangover. Let’s put it to test!

Ewan, the protagonist of our story reminded me so much of Harry from the ‘The Philosopher’s Stone’ that he could easily qualify as Harry for any layman, this is the level of similarity they share! Want examples? Well, let’s take a look at the way Ewan is described. Ewan looks a

‘little starved’

and his hair was

‘a stock standard fair brown; short, messy and stuck up oddly in various places’.

Remember Harry? He was frail and his messy, unkempt hair were talked about in almost all the books. Harry wasn’t able to control his magical powers which made him an outcast with the Dursleys while Ewan could see ‘Creatures’ that none around him could see which made him the odd one out in his various foster homes. This similitude doesn’t end there, even Firedrake Lyceum; Ewan’s school, shares similarities with Hogwarts. It has a

grand spiral staircase’

and Ewan’s dorm is described in the following words

‘The whole space was littered with couches and rugs and armchairs and normal tables and stools.’

Griffindor common room?

It is either heavily based on Harry Potter or I just found a little too many resemblances. The story so far is hinting on being totally Harry Potter-y but since this is the first book in a series, I hope it doesn’t.

Now, as I always do in my reviews, let’s talk about the first chapter. Ewan isn’t actually introduced in the first chapter, instead we meet Betony, an important character in the book. Betony’s secret mission is the focal point of the book. The first chapter does grab your attention because it has a lot of drama going on and there are layers of confusion too but it fails to maintain it because the writing gets a bit too descriptive or shall I say ‘flowery’. However, once you get through the initial chapters, the writing style improves and it is able to get you hooked!

Pity in one’s own downfalls without the sight to rejoice in your strengths is truly the road to ruin’

I like how the book’s main trio, Ewan and his friends Mathilde and Enid are given enough background. In fact, Mathilde and Enid do get a chapter or two of their own. Enola, the Grand Master of the Lyceum is another very interesting and mysterious character which can be developed in various ways in the future books (also wasn’t Dumbledore mysterious?). A character that I would like to see more of is Ewan’s very practical, very cool, very laid back, very gentleman-ly friend Rusty! I liked this side character more than Ewan at times! His few appearances in the book didn’t fail to impress me.

Moving on to the World-building, which in my opinion isn’t convincing enough and is the weakest part of the story. For me Hogwarts exists, but Firedrake’s existence is something I am not completely sure of! Why you ask? Firedrake is located in the city of London! How is that even feasible? If there was anything in this book that should have been taken from HP, it is the school’s location! Sure enough, there must be some magical thing-y in place to make it invisible to the lubbers (the muggles), but what would happen when students come out from the gates? It is not mentioned that Firedrake was in an isolated place, in fact there is a public park nearby, how could the lubbers not see the Lenitnes(that’s what Ewan and his fellows are called)? It smells of a plot hole.

I really liked the idea of Sorting students, there aren’t any hats or magical creatures that sort the students into their respective ‘cliques’. In fact, students aren’t sorted in their first year and they learn the subjects of all the different cliques. It is a better selection process, though if the Masters are involved in selecting the students for the cliques, the validity of the process will be under question. That is a thing we will get to know in book two.

The pace with which the plot develops is fairly neat. There is a lot going on at any given point to keep you hooked and the pace doesn’t slow down much. The plot is interesting, it is a different story that has become very eerily similar to Harry Potter, nevertheless, it is a completely different story. Ewan and Harry though being almost one and same, are different. Ewan has a different story to share which doesn’t involve He Who Must Not Be Named.

Although, I did not feel the same attachment to the book or the characters the way I did while reading Harry Potter, I do want to see what happens in the future books as there is indeed a lot of potential in it. The first book leaves all the right questions unanswered with a major cliffhanger and that is what will make me pick up the second book.

Would I recommend it to you? Tbh, it depends on who you are. If you are a touchy-feely HP fanatic, then no this probably isnt the book for you but if you enjoy reading HP fanfics or are into fantasy, then definitely give it a try!

Rating: ★★★1/2

Advertisements

6 thoughts on “Is this the cure for your Harry Potter hangover?

  1. Thanks so much for taking the time to read the book and review it – really means a lot! And thanks for putting it on Goodreads too!

    I thought I would though at least address your concerns with the location of Firedrake and its being able to be seen or not. You are right, this wasn’t explained at all in Book One, but owing to the other vast amount of things needed to be introduced in this first chapter of the story, it got left out for later. This particular factor is actually explained more in the upcoming Ewan Pendle and the Castle of Nightmares (out 31 October 2018 for anyone interested :P). However, in the location where the school exists in London there are a large number of buildings with outside open spaces which are surrounded by high walls, which if you go there today you are unable to see over without a tall ladder. Aside from this, much of the higher levels of Firedrake can indeed only been seen by Lenitnes, as they were coated in a certain substance many years ago, one which is made up from the by product of a certain creature … This gives these buildings the quality needed to be invisible to lubbers, but able to be seen by Lenitnes and creatures alike. Also, when the cadets venture out of the Firedrake it is only ever in there “street clothes”, so they would look just like any other group of kids walking around the city. And to be honest, London is such a weird and wonderful place, that if they did all go outside in their cadet clothes, they would barely get a sideways look from day to day Londoners 🙂

    As to the comparisons to Harry Potter, being a MASSIVE fan of it all myself, the similarities are all there intentionally. It’s flattering to have the work compared to such an untouchable series as HP, but these little bits are crafted into my story as a kind of homage to the world and the books of Harry Potter, which were an inspiration to me on many levels. Saying this, it is a book about a school of sorts, so there are going to be comparisons to other books with a similar setting regardless … Although, as Book Two kicks in, the comparisons to Harry might start to drop, as the story certainly gets darker and takes on a life of its own, drifting away from safe ground …

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you so much Shaun for taking the time to address my concerns. I really appreciate it! Now, that you have explained, I completely understand it. Being a very curious reader, I tend to look up every aspect of the book while I review to give a wholesome and honest perspective. I am glad that Book 2 is coming out 😀 I hope I am able to read it as I am really curious about one thing: Ewan’s clique 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

      1. No trouble at all! One of the main goals of the story is to make people curious about the details, so in actuality you’ve made me happy with your in depth review! I wish I had more readers just like you 🙂

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s